Stoke City vs Arsenal, 3-1: Full time analysis and player ratings
Written by Chris on May 8, 2011 20:30
The Game
“It is more rugby on the goalkeepers than football. When you see the way Shawcross kicked Heurelho Gomes, how Robert Huth pushed Gomes in the goal, you cannot say that is football anymore” – Arsene Wenger
Last year Arsene Wenger was accusing Tony Pulis of teaching “rugby”, and not football, to his players. Months later, Stoke City gave us the answer and we owe them an apology.
For the last six years our manager has been selling us the “next year will be the one” worthless arguments, showing disrespect to other teams including Tony Pulis and his Stoke players. He never asked us to be patient with Stoke, he never told us that today they are playing “rugby football” but tomorrow they will improve. In the end that is what they were doing, and today, he got the answer he deserved.
The team playing nice football this afternoon was not Arsenal and the team elbowing the opposition and making red-card tackles was not Stoke.
Jack twice deserved to get a red card and I honestly don’t want to imagine what would have happened if it was a Stoke player making such horrible tackles. A picture of Mark Halsey in a Stoke jersey maybe? Or numbers to show that there is a conspiracy against Arsenal?
What we witnessed today is the most shocking performance by Arsenal of the season, no heart, no desire, no fighting spirit, no determination. We again saw big, big problems in the defensive department, players who have no idea what defending means and those believing that this team is improving need to work very hard to convince us this is the case.
The first goal we conceded(27:06 if you’re watching the highlights) encapsulates to perfection what is wrong in defence with Johan Djourou busy marking Ryan Shawcross, Alex Song on Robert Huth and Laurent Koscielny staring at the two. No wonder Kenwyne Jones went on to score unmarked.
The season is now mathematically over as well and we will soon start a new summer of, “Yes, we will bring new players” then “We will sign new players if we find the right elements” only to then finally sign no-names from France or Belgium because established players would kill the career of the young ones.
And then the loop will start again. In the meantime, we just have to congratulate Manchester United for winning the title and aspiring for yet another treble. It happens when all your players go out there with the right winning mentality.
As always, whether you agree with my ratings or not, submit your own at Arsenal Interactive and make sure to share them on Twitter and Facebook.
Match Video Highlights
Match video highlights are available in the Videos section of our website. If not there yet, rest assured they will be up in a matter of hours.
Player Ratings
Szczesny: 6 – It would be harsh to blame him for the conceded goals. When you have such a pathetic defensive line in front of you, conceding three is understandable. Good save to deny Whelan in the 75th minute and keep the score 2-0.
Djourou: 3 – Today’s game clearly shows why we need an experienced defender back there, someone who knows what it means to “defend” when under pressure as I’m afraid you don’t win titles with players who are still learning the job.
Koscielny: 6 – Not as shocking as his partner at the heart of the defence but I wonder what he was thinking when we conceded the first two goals. Was marking Kenwyne Jones for the second, then he stopped, in no man’s land, giving more options to Pennant who could have easily passed it to the unmarked Jones.
Gibbs: 3 – Out of the frying pan and into the fire indeed. If Kieran calls himself a defender then there is something wrong back there. The way he let Glenn Whelan through in the 75th minute was embarrassing, no idea what was happening behind him.
Sagna: 5 – I expected more from Bacary when Jermaine Pennant surged forward to score the second and much, much more when Jonathan Walters turned him easily before hitting the bar.
Wilshere: 4,5 – Way too nervous and twice deserved to be sent off. Jack is a special player, I would say one of the best this season but he needs to grow up, he is to stop crying whenever decisions go against him and he is to control his temper.
Song: 5 – Incredibly poor. One of our best players in the first part of the season is now a shadow of himself, doing well only once every two months.
Ramsey: 4 – Shame, big shame. Started the game with a delicious through pass to Robin who fired high but then started to produce a number of unnecessary backheels and flicks that should be left in the training ground. No idea what he was thinking when we conceded the second.
Arshavin: 4,5 – Not enough. Again. Statistics may show that he produced 50 assists this season but the fact is that I can easily list 10-15 games in which he was shocking. Unnecessary push leading to Stoke’s first goal.
Walcott: 4,5 – Was he playing in the second half? Like Andrey, Theo has a long list of games in which he failed to make an impact.
van Persie: 6,5 – Wasted at least three half-chances, one in the 5th minute, one in the 57th and one in 78th. But still managed to score as I believe he is the only one who can leave the pitch with his head high.
(Subs)
Bendtner: 6 – I thought he had a very good game, compared to the rest at least. Never gave up and created important gaps for Robin in the final third.
Chamakh and Rosicky: No Vote – Marouane’s “shot” in the 52nd minute was embarrassing to see, he is maybe the only striker in the world who simply cannot shoot a football. I’m sure even a 33-year old Thierry Henry would have done better.



Arsenal News 24/7



Amen